Fantasy Baseball's AL or Nothing - AL Sleepers: Taking the Fifth!

by on March 6, 2014 @ 12:47:05 PDT


Pages 1 | 2 | all

By Ryan Carey

There are not many things that are more satisfying in fantasy than getting a breakout season out of one of your late-round pitchers. In deep or single-league formats, every team is going to have to take more than a few shots for the back of their rotations or on their benches, and those teams that hit on their picks sometimes reap the rewards of ace-level stats for their faith. Just ask anyone who was lucky enough to land Jose Fernandez last year. I speak from experience as I was able to land Fernandez in a bunch of leagues, and he helped me bring home two titles and another money finish in three separate leagues. The difference of course is I had to spend a sizeable chunk of my free agent budget to get him in every case. While he was still worth it in the end, it would have been even sweeter to have used a reserve round pick on him instead.

Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim SP Garrett Richards
Richards half of alluring LAA duo

I have already announced my affection for Drew Smyly this year as he slides into his new role as the TIgers' fifth starter. His price has been on the rise now that he has the job, and as such the odds of my rostering Smyly on more of my teams go down every day his draft stock rises. If someone in my league snipes me on Smyly, I will move along to some of my other sleeper picks in the American League. Here is a quick look at some of my other favorite arms that I think are poised to break out in 2014. I have drafted every one of these guys in at least one of my early leagues so far. Only time will tell if I hit the jackpot with any of my lottery tickets this year.

Carlos Carrasco, CLE - The Indians head into 2014 fresh off their first playoff berth since 2007 and with an internal belief that they can take the next step and even knock the vaunted Detroit Tigers off their perch atop the league's Central Division. It may seem like crazy talk, but they only came up one game short of that unlikely goal a year ago. The biggest question mark for the team this spring is who will step up and claim the fifth starter's job, vacated by the loss of Scott Kazmir in free agency.

Carrasco is my pick to emerge as the victor in a battle with Trevor Bauer, Josh Tomlin, Aaron Harang and Shaun Marcum for the coveted final spot. Carrasco is a former top prospect who came over from the Phillies in the Cliff Lee deal in 2009, and is the only one of the four players the Indians received in that deal still with the team. He showed some promise in 2011, before succumbing to Tommy John surgery and missing all of 2012. He made it back to the mound last year, and while he struggled with his control in seven mediocre starts, there were some positives for him to build on.

First and foremost was the increase in the velocity of his fastball, which went from an average of 92.5 mph to 95 mph. It is not uncommon for a player coming back from TJS to see an increase in velocity coupled with issues with control. This was certainly the case for Carrasco, who posted an ugly 6.75 ERA and 1.76 WHIP for the season last year. Were it not for some decent work out of the bullpen late in the year, those numbers would have been even worse.

On the bright side, he was pretty solid all year long in Triple-A, is still relatively young at 27 and will be two years removed from surgery. He also has always demonstrated a nice ground ball tendency, which should help him be successful if he can figure out how to harness his improved stuff. Since he is out of options, he's almost a shoo-in to get first crack at the job, but it is nice to see him show up to camp in good shape (he reportedly lost 15 pounds) and motivated to earn Terry Francona's trust. He has looked good early in camp, while Bauer is once again struggling with his control.

Yordano Ventura, KC - I will state up front that I am pretty high on Ventura this year, as I have already drafted him in two early 15-team leagues. In both cases, I got him just prior to the reserve rounds, a price that I think will look pretty nice by the time the season starts. See, I fully expect the young flamethrower to win the Royals' fifth starter job outright this spring.

His main competition for the job is Danny Duffy, with Wade Davis, Luke Hochevar, Chris Dwyer and Brad Penny also in the mix this spring. Hochevar was dominant out of the bullpen last year, and seems headed for that role again this year, especially now that he's injured. Davis regressed once he was moved back to starting last year, so I think he will start in the bullpen and hope to get another shot at some point this year.

So that leaves Duffy and Ventura, and I think when the dust settles, the team just won't be able to deny Ventura a rotation spot if they are serious about contending in the division this year. This isn't so much a condemnation of Duffy's skills, just more my belief that when you have a guy that can light up the radar gun like Ventura can, it's tough not to want to unleash him on opposing lineups. As with any young pitcher, the usual warning flags are in play here, but Ventura has a very nice curveball to complement his electric fastball, and also an improving changeup that is a work in progress.

The success of Fernandez, Tony Cingrani and a host of other young pitchers last year should provide enough reasons to not be afraid to take a shot at some upside at the draft table this year. Ventura, even if he starts the year in the pen or at Triple-A, won't stay in either spot long, and once he hits the rotation he will rack up strikeouts along with the league's best. Yes, he will get hit hard at times, especially if his change doesn't improve, but I don't see too many arms with his upside available late in drafts. The closer the season gets, the higher his price tag will get, so my advice is to try and get some shares in him while he's still a bargain.

Click for the rest of AL Sleepers: Taking the Fifth!

Facebook Twitter Google +

Pages 1 | 2 | all

About Fantasy Baseball

Mastersball, founded in 1997, is a leader in providing in-depth analysis, research, projections and applications to the advanced fantasy baseball player. A 2010 merger brought the writers of CREATiVESPORTS into the fold, widely known for 15 years of insightful fantasy analysis and commentary.

Don't miss these great reports....

What do you think? Sound off!

Recent KFFL releases